
“What is my ideal weight?”
It’s a question so many of us ask ourselves—but often, it’s not just about the number on the scale. Underneath it can live deeper emotions, self-judgment, and the quiet (but persistent) question: Am I enough?
In this week’s powerful new episode of the Thin Thinking Podcast, I’m joined by Rhona, who has released 25 pounds and maintained her progress. But our conversation didn’t start with the success—it started with a moment of self-reflection.
A few months ago, Rhona found herself wondering: Am I really at my ideal weight?
That one question opened up a much deeper dialogue—one about body image, self-acceptance, and redefining what success truly means on the journey of weight mastery.
This episode is about peeling back the layers:
- What really defines “ideal weight”?
- How do emotions and self-worth tie into the number on the scale?
- What does sustainable success actually look like?
Whether you’re on a weight release journey, navigating self-acceptance, or just want to hear a heartfelt, honest conversation—you don’t want to miss this one.
So come on in. Let’s go deeper.
May 28th through June 3rd
The Shift Self-Study 30-Day Hypnosis Based Weight Process
Start the program in your own time frame
- Discounted Price
- Get a ticket to the Live Fall Shift for FREE
- Additional Bonus Program: Shift Weight Express
In This Episode, You’ll Learn:
Who is Rhona and when did her struggles with weight began.
How and why the “ideal weight” varies person to person.
The way that you can use to identify your ideal weight.
Links Mentioned in this Episode
What is your ideal weight?
If that question feels loaded… you’re not imagining it. Because for many women, “ideal weight” isn’t just a number—it’s a verdict. A shortcut to answering the quieter, sharper question hiding underneath: “Am I enough?”
In this episode of the Thin Thinking Podcast, clinical hypnotherapist and weight mastery expert Rita Black pulls back the curtain on why the scale can feel like it runs your entire life. She’s joined by Rona, who released 25 pounds and has been maintaining for months—yet still found herself wondering, Should I lose more? Not because her body felt bad… but because the old mental math started again: If I can lose 25, shouldn’t I lose 30? 35?
And then Rita drops a truth that changes the whole conversation: “80% of our weight struggle is mental.”
This post will help you find a healthier, saner definition of ideal weight—one based on sustainability, self-trust, and real-life maintenance… not a chart from 1972 or a number your brain uses to punish you.
What does “ideal weight” actually mean for real life—not charts?
Ideal weight is the weight you can maintain while living a life you actually enjoy—without feeling deprived, obsessed, or at war with food.
That definition may sound almost too simple… until you’ve lived the alternative. Because the chart-driven approach usually goes like this:
- Pick a “goal” from a formula (the old “100 pounds at 5 feet + 5 pounds per inch” rule Rona mentions).
- Treat that number like a finish line.
- Push hard, restrict, white-knuckle your way there.
- Arrive… and still feel anxious, not good enough, and terrified of gaining.
Rita and Rona’s conversation highlights a crucial distinction: getting to a number and staying there are two different skill sets. A weight you can reach temporarily through pressure is not the same as a weight you can own.
Rona said something many women quietly relate to: she hit a number that felt good… and immediately wondered if it was enough. The charts said she could lose more and still be “healthy.” Her brain interpreted that as: Then I should.
But Rita’s response reframes the entire goal: try out the weight you’re at. Live there. Let your body and mind settle. Because your ideal weight isn’t a fantasy number—it’s a sustainable identity.
A practical “Ideal Weight” reality check
Ask yourself these three questions:
- Can I eat comfortably here? (Not perfectly. Comfortably.)
- Can I maintain this without constant mental effort?
- Do I feel strong, energized, and like myself?
If the answer is mostly yes, you may already be living closer to ideal than you think.
Why does the scale feel like it decides your worth?
The scale has power when it becomes a symbol—not just a measurement.
Rita opens the episode by naming what so many women experience: the “ideal weight” question often comes with deeper thoughts and emotions. It can morph into a judgment about your discipline, attractiveness, lovability, or value.
That’s why a two-pound fluctuation can feel like a crisis. Not because two pounds matter—but because what your brain makes it mean matters.
Rita explains how early messaging gets imprinted: from childhood into your twenties, experiences and comments become subconscious “truths.” Rona shares the cultural backdrop many women grew up in—Twiggy-thin ideals, the “thigh gap” mythology, and constant comparison. Rita adds her own vivid memory: believing that if she lost enough weight, she’d magically become an entirely different body type.
That’s the trap: when you treat weight as the key that unlocks worth, you’ll never feel done. Because your brain will always move the goalpost.
The hidden loop behind “ideal weight”
Here’s the loop many women live in (often without realizing it):
- “When I reach X, I’ll finally feel good enough.”
- Reach X.
- Still don’t feel good enough.
- Conclusion: “Then X wasn’t low enough.”
That’s not a weight problem. That’s a worth problem wearing a scale costume.
How do you know if you should lose more weight or maintain?
If losing more weight would require you to shrink your life, it’s not your ideal weight—it’s a new form of dieting.
This is where Rita’s coaching gets extremely practical. She shares that she once released more weight than she maintains today—then realized it wasn’t sustainable. That honesty matters, because it normalizes something powerful:
Sometimes your “goal weight” is achievable… but not livable.
Rona described choosing a pace of half a pound a week because she refused to starve herself or feel deprived. She wanted this to last, and it did. That’s what maintenance-minded weight release looks like: steady, calm, real-life compatible.
Use the “Sustainability Test”
Before you decide to lose more, test your current weight with this:
If I stayed at this weight for the next 12 months…
- Would I feel satisfied with how I eat?
- Would I feel confident in my routines?
- Would I feel mentally free most days?
If the answer is yes, consider this: maintenance may be the win your brain refuses to count.
And if the answer is no, the next step isn’t “push harder.” The next step is: which skill is missing? (Food relationship? Calorie budget clarity? Self-monitoring? Stress eating? Inner Critic management?)
That’s how you shift from scale-chasing to mastery.
What if you weigh more than you look—does that change your ideal weight?
Yes—because “ideal weight” must account for body composition, muscle density, and natural build, not just height.
Rita shares a fascinating point from her early career: after weighing many people, she noticed something that breaks the “numbers tell the truth” myth:
- Some people look small but weigh more (denser build, more muscle).
- Some people look larger but weigh less.
Rona relates deeply—she’s heard the classic nurse comment: “You don’t look like you weigh that much.” (Which is not helpful, by the way. It’s just another way to make the number louder.)
If you’re someone who builds muscle easily, has a naturally athletic build (often called a “mesomorph”), or carries weight differently, chart-based targets can be wildly misleading.
What to use instead of a single scale number
Consider tracking one or more of these alongside your weight:
- how your clothes fit
- strength goals (Rona’s goal: a chin-up/pull-up!)
- energy and sleep quality
- waist measurement or how your midsection feels (if this is relevant to your health goals)
- consistency with your calorie budget (for clarity, not punishment)
The scale can be data. It doesn’t get to be a judge.
How does menopause affect ideal weight and metabolism?
After menopause, many women need fewer calories than they think—and clarity beats guessing every time.
Rona’s story is a masterclass in what happens after menopause when you’re “eating healthy” but still gaining or stuck.
She even assumed something must be wrong—thyroid, metabolism, something—until her tests came back normal and her doctor told her to pay attention to how much and what she was eating.
Then came the turning point: data collection.
Rona admitted she initially resisted tracking because it sounded like “diet days.” But when she approached it like a scientist, she discovered the truth: even with whole foods, she was simply eating more than her body needed.
This matters because menopause often changes your baseline needs, and the old approach—“I eat pretty healthy”—stops being precise enough.
The reframe: tracking as self-respect, not restriction
Rita makes a key distinction: tracking isn’t about bean-counting or punishment. It’s about moving from emotional chaos to cognitive clarity.
When you know your actual needs, you regain choice:
- You can plan without panic.
- You can eat without the constant fear of “messing up.”
- You can maintain without living on willpower.
For many women, that’s when ideal weight stops being a mystery and becomes a skill.
How do you stop comparing your body to other people’s bodies?
Comparison keeps you chasing a moving target; self-leadership gives you a stable one.
Rona says it plainly: “Comparison is the thief of joy.” And she’s not just talking about bodies—she’s talking about life. Money. Success. Achievement. Even at 70, those old measuring sticks can still flare up.
And today, comparison is on steroids because your feed is engineered to show you someone “better”:
- fitter
- thinner
- richer
- more disciplined
- more “together”
Rita and Rona both name the cultural messaging they grew up with: be the perfect woman, do everything, look flawless doing it. That creates a pressure cocktail that shows up as: “Whatever I do isn’t enough.”
A simple “comparison interrupt”
When you catch yourself thinking, “She can, so I should,” ask:
- “What does my body need?”
- “What does my life require?”
- “What am I willing to sustain?”
Your ideal weight has to fit your nervous system, your schedule, your season of life—not a highlight reel.
What does it mean to “love yourself down the scale”?
Loving yourself down the scale means you don’t postpone self-respect until you reach a number—you practice it now, and the number follows.
This is one of the most powerful through-lines in the episode. Rita explains why people reach their “goal” and still don’t feel okay: they didn’t build self-acceptance on the way down. They used pressure, shame, and “not enough” as fuel.
So when they arrive, the mind doesn’t magically change. The self-judgment just looks for a new reason.
Rita shares a practice that supports real change: felt gratitude—not a list in your head, but a sensation in your body you learn to hold longer. That matters because your brain will default to scarcity: not thin enough, not disciplined enough, not successful enough.
Gratitude trains your nervous system to recognize: I am okay right now.
And from that place, you make different choices—calmer, cleaner, more aligned.
The permission moment (the real “ideal weight” breakthrough)
Rona said it: when Rita gave her permission to be okay where she was, something shifted. She relaxed—and ironically, she released a few more pounds without trying so hard.
That’s often how it works:
- pressure creates rebellion
- permission creates consistency
- consistency creates results
Ideal weight isn’t found through force. It’s found through ownership.
If you want support building self-trust and self-respect while releasing weight—rather than waiting to feel “enough” at a future number—listen to Episode 5 — 5 Hacks for Loving Yourself Down the Scale, which reinforces the mindset behind finding a truly sustainable ideal weight.
FAQ
1) What is the best way to find my ideal weight?
The best way is to find a weight you can maintain comfortably—where you feel strong, healthy, and mentally free—rather than chasing a chart number.
2) Is BMI a good measure of ideal weight?
BMI can be a starting point, but it doesn’t account for muscle mass, body composition, age, or build. Use it as information, not a verdict.
3) Why do I weigh more than I look?
Many people have denser builds or more muscle mass, which can increase scale weight without changing appearance. Body composition matters.
4) Should I lose more weight if charts say I can?
Not automatically. If losing more requires deprivation, obsession, or shrinking your life, it’s not a sustainable “ideal.” Test maintenance first.
5) How does menopause change my ideal weight?
Menopause can reduce the calories your body needs and change where weight is stored. Many women benefit from clearer tracking and strength-building.
6) How do I stop obsessing over the number on the scale?
Treat weight as data, not judgment. Focus on sustainable habits, how you feel, how clothes fit, and consistent self-monitoring without shame.
7) What if I reach my goal weight and still feel “not enough”?
That’s a sign the issue isn’t the number—it’s the meaning you attach to it. Mindset work (like hypnosis, coaching, or meditation) helps unwind that loop.
Conclusion
Your ideal weight is not the smallest number you can force your body into. It’s the weight you can live at—with food peace, self-trust, and a life that doesn’t revolve around punishment.
Rona’s story shows what mastery looks like: she released 25 pounds slowly, maintained it, and then faced the real question many women never name out loud: Is this enough?
And the answer Rita models is the one that changes everything: Give yourself permission to be okay. Try out your maintenance. Let your body and mind settle.Because the scale doesn’t get to decide your worth.
And you don’t have to earn “enough” by shrinking.
If you found this episode helpful, you might also enjoy this related Thin Thinking episode:
Subscribe and Review
Have you subscribed to the podcast yet? If not, go ahead and click the ‘subscribe’ button for your favorite podcast platform! You don’t want to miss a single episode.
If you enjoyed this episode, it would be very helpful to us if you would leave an honest review on Apple Podcasts. This review helps people who are on the same weight loss journey as you to find us and soak up all the wonderful insights and lessons I have to offer.
If you aren’t sure how to leave a review in Apple Podcasts/iTunes, view our tutorial by clicking here.