
Soon the winter months will be upon us…I got out my weighted winter blanket just the other night and said to myself “it’s that time.”
Like bears, humans seem to head to our caves and hibernate for the winter months.
It’s the season of binge watching, and binge eating. And can you blame us–mother nature has set our survival biology in this way.
However, bears do stop eating after putting on enough weight and sleep all winter–emerging from their cave in the spring thaw looking gaunt and thin–like they used all of their stored hibernation blubber.
For us humans–more times than not–we emerge in the spring–looking heavier than we did when we entered the cave… we somehow missed out on that sleeping all winter part!
Many of my clients and students in my online courses express concern about winter weight gain. They fear that the dark and cold will impede their progress or halt it altogether.
Never fear–this week, 87th episode of Thin Thinking, I dive into how to make some thin thinking shifts so that you can manage your weight easily during the dark and cold days of winter.
We also will do a vision exercise to inspire you to emerge from your cave this spring looking slim and confident.
In This Episode, You’ll Learn:
What are the weight challenges you will encounter during the the winter
Mental shifts you can make to stay on track with your weight mastery journey
How you can create a vision that will help you during the winter and emerge stronger in the future
Links Mentioned in this Episode
The cold wind blows… and suddenly the eating challenges get louder inside your head. If you’ve ever noticed that winter makes weight management feel harder, you’re not imagining it. In this episode of the Thin Thinking Podcast, Rita Black shares why winter triggers a very real “hibernation mindset”—and how to build a winter weight loss mindset that keeps you steady, strong, and on track.
Here’s the core truth Rita teaches: your weight struggle doesn’t start on your plate or get fixed in the gym—most of it starts in your mind. She puts it plainly: “80% of our weight struggle is mental.” And winter is when the mental game gets extra tricky—shorter days, less movement, more cravings, and for many people, mood shifts like Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD).
This post breaks down Rita’s “Thin Thinking for Winter Eating Challenges” into a clear plan you can use all season long—without pretending winter doesn’t exist. Because hope isn’t a strategy. A winter identity + winter plan is.
Why does winter make weight loss and maintenance harder?
Short answer: Winter changes your environment and your brain—so you need a winter strategy, not summer expectations.
One of the biggest winter mistakes Rita sees is this: people head into winter hoping they’ll keep doing what worked in summer. Longer days. More movement. Lighter meals. More natural momentum.
And then winter shows up like, “Cute plan.”
Rita describes it perfectly: “We aren’t really acknowledging we’re going into a whole other season. Our brains are changing, our bodies are changing with the seasons. And we really do need to adapt a whole new mindset around the winter.”
That means winter weight struggles aren’t just about willpower. They’re about predictable winter triggers:
- Shorter daylight hours → exercise routines get disrupted
- Colder weather → staying inside becomes the default
- More comfort cravings → heavier, carb-rich foods feel more appealing
- More TV / indoor routines → more opportunity for “hand-to-mouth snacking”
- Mood shifts and SAD → cravings + fatigue + low motivation
If you treat winter like summer, you’ll feel blindsided. If you treat winter like winter, you’ll feel prepared.
If winter feels emotionally heavier and food starts becoming a coping tool, you may also find value in Episode 211 — 10 Ways to Navigate Uncertain Times Without Reaching for Food, which expands on managing stress-driven eating when conditions feel harder and less predictable.
How do you build a “winter identity” that keeps you on track?
Short answer: Your winter identity drives your winter behavior—so choose it on purpose.
Rita starts winter mastery at the top: identity. Because if your identity is “I always gain weight in winter,” your brain will quietly try to prove you right.
She says it clearly: “When we have a limiting belief, identity about ourselves, that tends to… create that reality.”
So instead of repeating the old winter story, she teaches you to install a new one—on purpose. Here are a few identity statements she offers (and yes, they feel like a tongue twister at first):
- “I am a healthy person who manages my weight in the winter.”
- “I am a winter weight mastery warrior.”
- “I am creating my winter weight release.”
This isn’t pretending. This is training. You’re “re-seeing” yourself from a different vantage point—so your choices start matching the version of you you’re becoming.
Here’s a simple way to make this real (not fluffy):
- Pick one winter identity sentence
- Say it before your first food choice of the day
- Say it before you enter your biggest trigger zone (Costco, pantry, couch-at-night)
Because winter isn’t the time to “wing it.” Winter is the time to lead yourself.
What’s a realistic winter exercise plan when it’s dark and cold?
Short answer: Winter exercise works when you stop relying on perfect conditions and start using a Plan B.
Rita’s first major winter challenge is movement. Not because you “don’t care,” but because winter makes movement harder:
- It’s dark when you used to walk
- It’s cold when you used to run
- It might be unsafe, icy, or just miserable outside
So the solution isn’t “try harder.” The solution is a winter plan.
1) Break up your movement across the day
Instead of one perfect 45-minute walk, Rita suggests splitting it:
- 15 minutes in the morning
- 15 minutes at lunch
- 10 minutes in the afternoon
Same energy output. Less friction. And it gives your brain a break—which it needs.
She also mentions clients who create a mini walking group at work. That’s sneaky brilliance: you turn movement into social momentum.
2) Create “Plan B exercise” (non-negotiable backup)
Rita loves a Plan B: “If I don’t get my exercise in… that means I’ve got that plan B.”
Examples she gives:
- A dance party (yes, seriously—“dance your buns off”)
- A YouTube yoga session
- HIIT at home
- Anything that keeps you moving when the weather blocks Plan A
3) Push more exercise to the weekend (and remove guilt)
If weekdays are tight, shift more movement to Saturday and Sunday—longer sessions that reduce weekday pressure. It’s not “ideal,” but it’s effective.
4) Use habit stacking so exercise happens automatically
One of the most usable gems in the episode: anchor movement to something you already do.
Rita’s example: she puts the tea kettle on, and for the time it takes to boil, she does mobility, stretching, balance—10 to 15 minutes.
You can do the same with:
- Coffee brewing
- A shower warming up
- A Zoom meeting ending
- The microwave running
This matters because winter success comes from low-drama consistency, not intensity.
5) Consider “under-desk movement” for winter evenings
Rita mentions a client using a “Cubii” (under-desk elliptical) while working or watching TV. The big idea isn’t the product—it’s this:
If winter makes you sit more, build movement into sitting time.
How do you stop winter snacking and “hibernation eating”?
Short answer: Winter cravings are partly biological—so you need environmental boundaries, not endless self-control.
Rita’s second major winter challenge is what she calls “hibernation mode.” She shares a bear documentary story where bears rapidly gain weight before winter, and then she connects the dots:
“Research shows that we are driven biologically to eat more heavy comfort foods in the winter time to store weight.”
And here’s the kicker: your “shutoff valve” gets weaker in winter.
That means if your plan is “I’ll just have a little,” winter might laugh in your face.
So what do you do?
Make your house your winter “cave”—and protect it
Rita gives a strong metaphor: treat your home like a cave you protect like a mama bear. Not from other people—sometimes from your own inner rebel.
She says it plainly: “Think of your house as your cave and be protective of it like a mama bear, even against that inner rebel in your head.”
This is stimulus control, winter edition.
Create a “Not An Option” food list
One of the most practical strategies in the episode is removing trigger foods from your environment—especially in winter.
Rita frames it as power, not deprivation:
- You’re not a victim.
- You’re advocating for the future you.
- You’re building a cave that supports you.
She calls out the trap: buying trigger foods and promising yourself “just one.” If it’s a true trigger, your brain won’t stop at one—especially in winter.
What should you eat in winter when you want comfort food?
Short answer: You don’t need to stop wanting comfort—you need to upgrade what comfort is made of.
Rita doesn’t tell you to eat cold salads and pretend you’re fine. She basically says, “Of course you want comfort food—so let’s make comfort work for you.”
Here are winter comfort options she shares that are warm, filling, and stabilizing:
Winter comfort foods that still support weight mastery
- Soups (warm, filling, low effort)
- Roasted vegetables (broccoli with olive oil, salt, pepper, garlic)
- Hardier salads (kale + warm sautéed veggies + protein)
- Greek yogurt + pumpkin pie spice
- “Roasted” apple (slice + microwave ~3 minutes)
- Sweet potato (comfort + fiber)
- Oatmeal + egg whites “cupcake” (oatmeal + egg whites + cinnamon + stevia → microwave into a cake-like snack)
And she highlights something surprisingly powerful: tea as comfort. Not as a sad substitute—real comfort.
Because winter comfort isn’t the enemy. The problem is when your comfort is built from foods that keep your brain in “more-more-more” mode.
Rita uses her word for those refined trigger foods: “gawki”—low nutrition, high “snack gravity.”
Winter win: make comfort warm and nourishing.
How can fasting after dinner become your winter “shutoff valve”?
Short answer: A clear rule beats a constant debate—especially at night in winter.
Night eating is a classic winter trap: TV, cozy vibes, snack loops (salty → sweet → crunchy → “just one more”).
Rita suggests a simple boundary: fast after dinner.
And what’s smart here is how she frames it:
- Instead of “trying not to eat,” you’re “actively fasting.”
- It becomes a choice you’re making, not a temptation you’re fighting.
She describes the mindset like this: “Getting up from the dinner table and just being done… food isn’t an option between now and then.”
This works well in winter because it stops decision fatigue. You don’t have to keep negotiating with yourself at 9:42 p.m. You already decided.
How do you handle Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD) without eating through it?
Short answer: If winter messes with your mood, your food choices will feel harder—so support your brain first.
Rita’s third winter challenge is Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD)—and she’s personal about it: she experienced depression in dark climates (like London and Seattle winters), especially January through March.
She also lists common SAD symptoms:
- low energy
- ongoing sadness
- excessive sleepiness
- increased appetite
- cravings for sugary/carb-rich foods
If this sounds like you, Rita suggests speaking with a doctor. From there, she shares supportive strategies that reduce the urge to medicate winter with food:
Practical winter mood supports (that don’t involve snacks)
- Light therapy (especially in darker climates)
- Exercise (strong antidepressant effect for many people)
- Vitamin D (check with your doctor)
- Daily self-care rituals (candle + bath, journaling, gratitude)
- Stay social even when you’re staying in (Zoom hangs can be a winter lifeline)
- Volunteering / helping others (boosts meaning and mood)
- Comedy on standby (her idea: “comfort laughing instead of comfort food”)
- Regular bedtime (sleep routine matters more in winter)
That comedy idea is sneaky and effective: when you want a snack but you’re not hungry, you might really be seeking a state change—comfort, relief, stimulation. Laughter delivers that without the snack spiral.
What’s the spring vision exercise—and why does it work?
Short answer: A vivid spring vision pulls you through winter when motivation fades.
Rita teaches something most people skip: use spring as a motivational magnet.
Instead of white-knuckling winter, you create a vision of “you in late April” and let that identity guide your daily choices.
In the episode, she leads a visualization—breath, body awareness, then imagining yourself in spring:
- what you’re wearing
- how you feel
- how much weight you’ve released (or how steady you’ve stayed)
- how proud you are that you made winter work
She also has you imagine very specific wins:
- walking past unhealthy foods in the store and feeling proud
- being “done” after dinner
- choosing warm, nourishing foods that make you feel stable
Then she anchors it with mantras like:
- “I am a winter weight mastery warrior.”
- “I love moving my body every day of the winter.”
- “The healthier the foods are, the more comforting they are.”
- “Healthy is warm.”
- “My cave is a healthy haven.”
Whether you love visualization or roll your eyes at it, the mechanism is simple: your brain organizes behavior around the future you keep rehearsing.
Winter becomes easier when you’re not just “trying to behave.” You’re protecting a future you.
FAQ: Thin Thinking for Winter Eating Challenges
1) Why do I crave carbs more in winter?
Winter can push your body and brain toward “hibernation mode,” which often increases cravings for heavier comfort foods and makes your “stop” signal weaker.
2) What’s the fastest mindset shift for winter weight management?
Choose a new winter identity and repeat it daily—like: “I am a healthy person who manages my weight in the winter.” Identity drives behavior.
3) How do I exercise when it’s dark before and after work?
Use a winter plan: break movement into smaller chunks, move more on weekends, and create a Plan B workout you can do indoors.
4) What should I do if I always snack at night in winter?
Create a shutoff valve by fasting after dinner. A clear boundary prevents the nightly snack debate from starting.
5) Should I keep trigger foods in the house and “learn moderation”?
If a food reliably takes your power away, winter is not the time to test yourself. Remove it and stock foods that stabilize you.
6) What are healthy comfort foods for winter cravings?
Soups, roasted vegetables, hardier salads, sweet potatoes, oatmeal-based snacks with protein, roasted apples, and tea are all warm and satisfying options.
7) How do I know if I have Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD)?
Common signs include low energy, persistent sadness, increased sleepiness, increased appetite, and cravings for carbs/sugar in winter. Consider talking with your doctor.
Conclusion
Winter doesn’t ruin your progress—winter exposes whether you have a winter plan. And the plan Rita teaches is clear:
- Install a winter identity (stop predicting failure)
- Build a realistic winter movement strategy (Plan A + Plan B + habit stacking)
- Protect your “cave” (remove trigger foods, stock stabilizing comfort foods)
- Use a shutoff valve at night (fast after dinner)
- Support your winter brain (especially if SAD or low mood is part of your pattern)
- Let spring pull you forward (vision creates follow-through)
You can absolutely create a powerful winter—one where you feel proud, steady, and in charge. As Rita says, “We can create a healthy, powerful, fulfilling winter… showing up for ourselves like a mama bear.”
If you found this episode helpful, you might also enjoy this related Thin Thinking episode: